Talk:Wind Dungeon

Page name
Shouldn't this page be titled, "Air Dungeon" or "Wind Dungeon"? I don't know about you guys, but when I hear "Sky Dungeon," I think of dungeons like the Palace of Winds and the City in the Sky, not dungeons like the Wind Temple and the Tower of Hera. Sir Real 16:23, 2 April 2011 (EDT)


 * Hmm, good question, but Sky Dungeon seems to fit the criteria considering all of these dungeons are located in the sky ;) 21:09, April 2, 2011 (UTC)


 * Not really. I guess the Tower of Hera and the Ancient Ruins are technically in the sky, considering that they're on top of mountains, but wouldn't that make a lot of other dungeons Sky Dungeons as well? Also, the Wind Temple isn't in the sky, it's underground. Sir Real 15:43, 3 April 2011 (EDT)


 * The Tower of Hera and the Ancient Ruins are also really tall towers, "sky-scrapers", if you will. They're in the skies, so therefore they are sky dungeons and other dungeons on top of mountains are not. "Sky Temple" encompasses all these dungeons better than any other term does; all the wind dungeons are in the sky, but not all the dungeons themselves actually have a wind theme. The Wind Temple is really the only exception. We could say "Air Dungeon", but that seems like too general a term to me.


 * So here's the rundown: We have to choose between keeping it as "Sky Dungeon", or changing it to "Wind Dungeon or "Air Dungeon". "Air Dungeon" doesn't really identify any of them all that well; "Wind Dungeon" identifies some of them properly; "Sky Dungeon" identifies all of them pretty well, with one exception.


 * I'm leaning towards keeping "Sky Dungeon". 16:50, 3 April 2011 (EDT)