Talk:Spume

Change "Aqua Spume" to "Spume"
EpicDude25 is proposing that we change the Aqua Spume section to just Spume based on a line from the official handguide, where it says to "look out for the annoying green Spume". However, I disagree because I don't think the handguide is claiming it to be the spume, but rather it's referring to it as a Spume and that the handguide is referring to it as "the green Spume" because there's no official name. Furthermore, this change would showcase the Aqua Spume as the primary member of its species. In other cases, the "primary member" is the most common and typically the first one to be encountered. However, Aqua Spumes are arguably the least common and Magma Spumes are encountered first. 15:43, 23 January 2012 (EST)


 * Hey I just want to say that even though they are the last encountered and least common type of Spume, doesn't mean that they aren't the "primary member." Also take note that they appear when a Timeshift Stone has been used, which further backs me up on the fact that they are the "primary member" because Timeshift Stones take you back like 1,000 into the past--EpicDude25 18:10 23 January 2012

I disagree with changing the name, there is no official name for the Aqua Spume because Fi is unable to analyze it on Skipper's Boat. I would support keeping the name Aqua Spume which reflects its habitat and its behavior. XXSuperXXNintendoXx 21:27, 23 January 2012 (EST)
 * @EpicDude25: I didn't mean chronologically. The appearance of Timeshift Stones would have absolutely no bearing on their appearance game-play wise (mind you, following that logic, would Technoblins be considered the "primary members"?). Regardless, take a look at other enemies; traditionally, the "basic" member is introduced first, with tougher variations introduced later (Keese -> Fire Keese). However, I don't believe that the Spumes even have a basic/primary form, so the article should be left as-is. 21:35, 23 January 2012 (EST)


 * "Annoying green Spume"? That doesn't sound too professional :P Anyway, I think we should keep it as-is for the reasons mentioned above. Also, Timeshift Stones are not found outside the desert, so you can't rule out the possibility that Magma and Cursed Spumes existed in Eldin Volcano in the past. 04:06, 24 January 2012 (EST)