Talk:SoulCalibur II

Name
Technically, the title is Soulcalibur II. This should be altered. Saibh 11:32, 28 March 2008 (EDT)


 * Actually, Namco's sites for the games consistantly type it out as "SOULCALIBUR"... So perhaps the article should be moved to "SOULCALIBUR II"? --Ando (T : C) 14:50, 28 March 2008 (EDT)


 * Okay, I've got the game loaded up on my GameCube right now. All of the good soul weapons, there are three (Nightmare's, Xiangua's, and Talim's), are called "Soul Calibur". The title on the title screen is "Soul Calibur II". No matter how Namco likes to mess up the title on its site, the game's title is "Soul Calibur II". That's it. A move is in order. 02:21, July 4, 2008 (UTC)

I'm not so sure here. Why would Namco consistently spell it out in all caps, as one word? Look at this press release for the third game. But to be fair, this is all for the third game... I'm having a much more difficult time finding convincing evidence towards the second game's spelling. What to do, what to do? 05:45, 4 July 2008 (UTC)


 * Well, the game is named after the sword. The sword is called "Soul Calibur". Therefore, the logical name is "Soul Calibur II". I'm not entirely sure on this, but I think that Namco likes to refer to its games in caps because of its history with arcade games. Many arcade games are limited to capital letters only. So Namco's spelling its games in caps is just a habit, not the actual name. Remember that the Nintendo system in question is called the GameCube, but the word on the system itself is "GAMECUBE". It is just a habit that companies have because they think it would look better in that situation. In this case, "SOULCALIBUR II" is an incorrect title and is not appropriate for a wiki. "Soul Calibur II" is the proper title. 06:14, July 4, 2008 (UTC)


 * according to the game, the name is SOULCALIBUR II.

I own the game. I'm reading the case, even as I type this. Throughout the booklet, the title is written like this, eg.

"Place the SOULCALIBUR II disc on the disc tray with the label facing up and close the disk tray."

An excerpt from the instruction booklet, that. --Yuvorias, 17:55, 4 July 2008 (EST)


 * Regarding the GameCube, that's mildly different in that the console itself has the logo -- logos can have entirely different capitalization than what the company actually wants. But then again, you say that if the game itself says "Soul Calibur II", that should be the title, not what Namco says. If so, then if the GameCube itself says "GAMECUBE", should not that be the title as opposed to what Nintendo says? Obviously not, as it's referred to as such in one or two instances (in this case, the logo and the logo alone). Throughout the manual and all of Nintendo's press releases and promotional material, they spell it as "GameCube", which is exactly the same scenario as Namco and "Soul Calibur / SOULCALIBUR". 14:25, 4 July 2008 (UTC)


 * I suggest: moving this page to Soul Calibur II, then stating in the article that the game is also referred to as "SOULCALIBUR II". Fair enough? 14:34, July 4, 2008 (UTC)


 * I'll still hold that "SOULCALIBUR II" is the proper title, but I think that I can live with this. 14:36, 4 July 2008 (UTC)

Wait a second. Wikipedia has the article titles for each of the games as a combination of the two: "Soulcalibur". Perhaps we should go with this? I believe that there are two different ways of typing the phrase, personally: The weapon is "Soul Calibur", but the game is "Soulcalibur".

Soulcalibur is now officially one word, no longer two, and plus why  the  hell  is it in  all  caps!?!?


 * The above discussion explains all of that. 00:38, 12 July 2008 (UTC)

I read it, and sites  and things that  promote or  publish something write their products in  all caps to     make it    seem  more Attention   catching,   such as    I have  an old  walkthrough guide  for   the  classic  Doom  II  and  everytime   when  "Doom II" was written it    always was  written  such  as "DOOM  II"  this article  should  have lowercase  letters in the sense of how it  does in the Wikipedia  article  for this game.


 * That makes sense. Well, I think a delete and a move is in order. From this and the way the title is pronounced in the game, the title is "Soul Calibur II". 05:32, July 14, 2008 (UTC)

It should  be  done  imidiately,   the title of this article  ridicules the actual game name.


 * Okay, okay, hang on. I'd like a vote on this, to make it easier to see where we all stand. Poll closes in a week (7/24/08). 22:45, 17 July 2008 (UTC)

SUPPORT FOR "Soulcalibur II" SUPPORT FOR "Soul Calibur II"
 * 1) Though I prefer the page's current title, this seems to be a nice bridge between the two forces (and also what Wikipedia uses, for what it's worth). 22:45, 17 July 2008 (UTC)
 * 2) The game has it as one word. Therefore, it is to be 1 word. 23:08, 17 July 2008 (UTC)
 * 3) The first Soulcalibur game was two words, and I have owned Soulcalibur II for over 5 years now, I beat it when I was 10, and don't even play it anymore, just because the title is "Soulcalibur" doesn't mean the sword name is one word too. Also proof on Wikipedia . I pay my regards to one word, the only thing that really borthers me is that  it's in all caps.
 * 1) First of all, in the opening screen of the game, it is pronounced as two words. There is a significant pause between them. So long of a pause that it cannot possibly be one word. The game is named after the weapon. The weapon's name is "Soul Calibur". That is two words. As far as the title on the title screen looking like one word, the disks for many Harry Potter games have what looks like "HarryPotter". A few Star Wars games look like "STARWARS". But take notice that the "C" in the title for the game in question is really big. That classically means another word is started and the normal space is left out because the big letter would serve the same function. So the title is "Soul Calibur II". 23:24, July 17, 2008 (UTC)