User talk:Smighty

Theories in articles
Hey, dude. I noticed you had a really large edit to Bongo Bongo which was reverted. Just wanted to stop by and let you know that our policy on theories is to only display those which have a viable basis in the series and are widely renowned by the community. Your own personal theories may not be placed in articles. If you feel you have a theory with a good enough background to be in the article, try making a talk page message explaining it to see if the other users agree. You are also welcome to post your own theories on your Userpage.

And that's all. Just wanted to let you know why your work was reverted. Happy editing! 18:07, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

I appreciate your input, Justin and apologise that I didn't brief the policy clearly. If I'm to repost these theories I'll certainly look for further evidence regarding their authenticity. Thanks for taking the time to send this message, and I'll be sure not to make the same mistake again.

However, I was wondering... If you had the time to answer my queries that is, would the Wiki benefit from combat statistics and alternative strategies to bosses? For example, the boss's HP which is accumulated through the amount of hits and the power of the weapon i.e. 4 hits from Master Sword = 2 hits from Biggoron's Sword: 1 jump attack/spin attack and results are 8 HP or 8 hits from Kokiri Sword. It would be done neater than this. Some alternate strategies are not in the Wiki, such as the Ice Arrow on Bongo Bongo and attacking Queen Gohma while she produces Gohma Eggs. I've been replaying my old OoT and looking at your lovely Wiki. Finding out that it's possible to contribute I'd be more than happy to experiment all possible options with different enemies and Bosses, provided it was needed that is. Smighty 8:33 pm, 22 March 2013


 * I don't think this is the first time someone's brought up the concept of listing all the enemies' HP. I personally rather like the idea. A page on enemy HP would really compliment our Weapon Strength article and it might be something we could eventually incorporate into the Enemy infobox or something. I would suggest you bring this proposal to Zelda Wiki:Hyrule Castle where all the ZW editors can see it, so that people can leave their input.


 * I also don't see any problem with adding alternative strategies, it's relevant information. It's not like we're a walkthrough site where the goal is to only list the most direct method. 19:58, 22 March 2013 (UTC)