87,822
edits
Talk:Sanctuary (A Link Between Worlds): Difference between revisions
From Zelda Wiki, the Zelda encyclopedia
Talk:Sanctuary (A Link Between Worlds) (view source)
Revision as of 03:14, 11 April 2016
, 11 April 2016→Merge with Sanctuary (A Link to the Past)
No edit summary |
TriforceTony (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
::::::That TP Sanctuary is a completely different place. It's like asking to merge the Pirate Ships from Skyward Sword and Wind Waker. Now I've probably given you an idea, though, hehe. I personally don't like this sort of issue: sometimes seeing what the benefits are in person can convince more than the most elaborate words. I mean to say let's merge it, do it well, and see what it looks like instead of standing around asking people if its a good idea. If people have legit criticisms to lobby after actually seeing the thing, then we can debate. The mods move and rename stuff all the time without asking, and arbitrarily at that, yet this one is an issue. Please excuse my lecture on wiki editing philosophy, but sometimes things don't make much sense around here. In fact, the name Sanctuary (Era of L&D) works a little bit better than you abruptly made it out to, because LttP Sanctuary IS in that era, and the LBW Sanctuary is the same place. So that LBW Sanctuary was in that era at some point, currently or not. It's not perfect, but really, there is like no consistency on this wiki on what flies and what doesn't and it's starting to get to me. Sorry. [[User:JasonBall|JasonBall]] ([[User talk:JasonBall|talk]]) 22:31, 10 April 2016 (UTC) | ::::::That TP Sanctuary is a completely different place. It's like asking to merge the Pirate Ships from Skyward Sword and Wind Waker. Now I've probably given you an idea, though, hehe. I personally don't like this sort of issue: sometimes seeing what the benefits are in person can convince more than the most elaborate words. I mean to say let's merge it, do it well, and see what it looks like instead of standing around asking people if its a good idea. If people have legit criticisms to lobby after actually seeing the thing, then we can debate. The mods move and rename stuff all the time without asking, and arbitrarily at that, yet this one is an issue. Please excuse my lecture on wiki editing philosophy, but sometimes things don't make much sense around here. In fact, the name Sanctuary (Era of L&D) works a little bit better than you abruptly made it out to, because LttP Sanctuary IS in that era, and the LBW Sanctuary is the same place. So that LBW Sanctuary was in that era at some point, currently or not. It's not perfect, but really, there is like no consistency on this wiki on what flies and what doesn't and it's starting to get to me. Sorry. [[User:JasonBall|JasonBall]] ([[User talk:JasonBall|talk]]) 22:31, 10 April 2016 (UTC) | ||
:I agree even if we have to merge all three Sanctuaries. But, as JasonBall said, while the ''ALttP'' and ''ALBW'' sanctuaries are the same at different time (past/future), the Sanctuary in ''TP'' is in another universe (and not confirmed to serve the same purpose as the other unverse's sanctuary). [[User:Jeangabin|Jeangabin]] ([[User talk:Jeangabin|talk]]) 23:45, 10 April 2016 (UTC) | :I agree even if we have to merge all three Sanctuaries. But, as JasonBall said, while the ''ALttP'' and ''ALBW'' sanctuaries are the same at different time (past/future), the Sanctuary in ''TP'' is in another universe (and not confirmed to serve the same purpose as the other unverse's sanctuary). [[User:Jeangabin|Jeangabin]] ([[User talk:Jeangabin|talk]]) 23:45, 10 April 2016 (UTC) | ||
::The [[Temple of Time]] page hosts information for "completely different places" and is nonetheless unaffected. The Priests in ALttP and ALBW are "completely different people", yet they share a page. The question therein is: what makes these Sanctuaries any more special to deserve special treatment? | |||
::By the "Pirate Ship" from ''Skyward Sword'', I assume you mean the [[Sandship]], which has its own name. No conflict, no comparison. No such thing as "Pirate Ship" in ''The Wind Waker'' either (there's ''[[Tetra's Ship]]'' and ''[[Warship]]s'', but see: Sandship). | |||
::In response to your criticism of administrator activity: they are more than likely carrying out policy that they have been taught and are not guilty of carrying out wanton activity. {{:User:Tony/sig}} 03:14, 11 April 2016 (UTC) | |||
