87,252
edits
Talk:Gohma: Difference between revisions
From Zelda Wiki, the Zelda encyclopedia
Undid revision 428191 by Minuet of forest (Talk)
No edit summary |
TriforceTony (talk | contribs) (Undid revision 428191 by Minuet of forest (Talk)) |
||
| Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
I think we should them all together, all of them but TWW's, the only similarities between the one from The Wind Waker and the others is that A) It's weakness are it's eyes. B) It's an anthropod? No scratch that. It's like saying a computer and encyclopedia are the same things just because you can find information on it... Okay that's a terrible analogy but I think you guys get my point. [[User:Steahl|Steahl]] 14:43, 13 November 2011 (EST) | I think we should them all together, all of them but TWW's, the only similarities between the one from The Wind Waker and the others is that A) It's weakness are it's eyes. B) It's an anthropod? No scratch that. It's like saying a computer and encyclopedia are the same things just because you can find information on it... Okay that's a terrible analogy but I think you guys get my point. [[User:Steahl|Steahl]] 14:43, 13 November 2011 (EST) | ||
:It would be mighty difficult to simply differentiate the Gohmas who are not entirely unique, such as LTHP and LOZ and such, however I'm sure there is textual evidence which help separate them. Such as, Queen Ghoma from OoT is referenced as an arachnid when quite obviously she does not have 8 legs. The denizens of the usurped tree seem to worship her, and there could be more on that and perhaps her hatchings can be contained in that page. However, why not put the basic Gohmas together on the page and just have a link and a picture to another page? Besides, if I'm not mistaken there is a water like Gohma in Twilight Princess that is not referenced in the Gohma page? --{{nosig|Smighty|02:12, March 21, 2013}} | :It would be mighty difficult to simply differentiate the Gohmas who are not entirely unique, such as LTHP and LOZ and such, however I'm sure there is textual evidence which help separate them. Such as, Queen Ghoma from OoT is referenced as an arachnid when quite obviously she does not have 8 legs. The denizens of the usurped tree seem to worship her, and there could be more on that and perhaps her hatchings can be contained in that page. However, why not put the basic Gohmas together on the page and just have a link and a picture to another page? Besides, if I'm not mistaken there is a water like Gohma in Twilight Princess that is not referenced in the Gohma page? --{{nosig|Smighty|02:12, March 21, 2013}} | ||
| Line 90: | Line 89: | ||
How about making the non-canon appearances into it's own page instead of making separate pages for Ocarina of Time and Wind Waker's canon ones if it will be split? ([[User:Nightmare Lyra|Nightmare Lyra]] ([[User talk:Nightmare Lyra|talk]]) 23:35, 5 October 2014 (UTC)) | How about making the non-canon appearances into it's own page instead of making separate pages for Ocarina of Time and Wind Waker's canon ones if it will be split? ([[User:Nightmare Lyra|Nightmare Lyra]] ([[User talk:Nightmare Lyra|talk]]) 23:35, 5 October 2014 (UTC)) | ||
:Yes I completely agree with you (Steahl), due to Gohma from TWW being a giant magtail. [[User:Minuet of forest|Minuet of forest]] | |||
==Split Discussion Round 2== | |||
Since the previous discussion got too long and spans back four whole years, let's start up a new discussion towards whether or not to split, with our current community.<br>I say we keep it on one page. If we feel the page is too long, we can always go the route of giving the Other Appearances section its own page. {{:User:Pakkun/sig}} 02:31, 11 January 2015 (UTC) | |||
