Talk:Monita: Difference between revisions
Latest comment: 11 January 2013 by Yruag in topic Appropriate?
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
::I'm sorry, but that still doesn't make her a notable character in a Zelda game. Just because the prizes are Zelda related doesn't mean that it's a Zelda game. I understand you put a lot of effort into making the page, and I really respect that, but it's just part of our policy that we don't cover stuff like this, especially with our NIWA affiliations.{{:User:Justin/sig}} 05:33, 7 January 2013 (UTC) | ::I'm sorry, but that still doesn't make her a notable character in a Zelda game. Just because the prizes are Zelda related doesn't mean that it's a Zelda game. I understand you put a lot of effort into making the page, and I really respect that, but it's just part of our policy that we don't cover stuff like this, especially with our NIWA affiliations.{{:User:Justin/sig}} 05:33, 7 January 2013 (UTC) | ||
:::Going by ZeldaWiki.org's [[Zelda_Wiki:Canon_Policy|canon policy]], Monita is not canon. There are some articles on the wiki about non canon games, such as [[Soulcalibur II]] more so than non-canon characters like Mario. I have not played Nintendoland, but from what I have seen, the only characters are Miis. It generally seems that non-canon characters only get an article on the wiki when connected directly to a non-canon game, such as [[Super Smash Bros. Brawl]]. Going by this, in my opinion, there is not enough connection for the article to be relevant in any meaningful way. Therefore, the page should be deleted or redirected to another wiki if ZeldaWiki.org still has that policy. {{:User:Yruag/sig}} 11:09, 11 January 2013 (UTC) | :::Going by ZeldaWiki.org's [[Zelda_Wiki:Canon_Policy|canon policy]], Monita is not canon. There are some articles on the wiki about non canon games, such as [[Soulcalibur II]] more so than non-canon characters like Mario. I have not played Nintendoland, but from what I have seen, the only characters are Miis. It generally seems that non-canon characters only get an article on the wiki when connected directly to a non-canon game, such as [[Super Smash Bros. Brawl]]. Going by this, in my opinion, there is not enough connection for the article to be relevant in any meaningful way. Therefore, the page should be deleted or redirected to another wiki if ZeldaWiki.org still has that policy. {{:User:Yruag/sig}} 11:09, 11 January 2013 (UTC) | ||
::::Well, [[Ganon]] appears in it. {{:User:NorskTW/sig}} 15:23, 11 January 2013 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 15:23, 11 January 2013
Appropriate?
I'm not sure what Nintendo Land is, but I know that it's not Zelda, and that we generally don't make articles for characters not from the Zelda universe who do not play some sort of role in a Zelda game. As such, I don't feel that this article is appropriate for Zelda Wiki. Perhaps this would be better served as a redirect to the appropriate page on another wiki (whatever wiki which cover Nintendo Land, to be specific).User:Justin/sig 18:31, 6 January 2013 (UTC)
- She makes comments on the prizes won on the top of the central tower, some of which are zelda related User:NorskTW/sig 19:26, 6 January 2013 (UTC)
- I'm sorry, but that still doesn't make her a notable character in a Zelda game. Just because the prizes are Zelda related doesn't mean that it's a Zelda game. I understand you put a lot of effort into making the page, and I really respect that, but it's just part of our policy that we don't cover stuff like this, especially with our NIWA affiliations.User:Justin/sig 05:33, 7 January 2013 (UTC)
- Going by ZeldaWiki.org's canon policy, Monita is not canon. There are some articles on the wiki about non canon games, such as Soulcalibur II more so than non-canon characters like Mario. I have not played Nintendoland, but from what I have seen, the only characters are Miis. It generally seems that non-canon characters only get an article on the wiki when connected directly to a non-canon game, such as Super Smash Bros. Brawl. Going by this, in my opinion, there is not enough connection for the article to be relevant in any meaningful way. Therefore, the page should be deleted or redirected to another wiki if ZeldaWiki.org still has that policy. —Yruag 11:09, 11 January 2013 (UTC)
- Well, Ganon appears in it. User:NorskTW/sig 15:23, 11 January 2013 (UTC)
- Going by ZeldaWiki.org's canon policy, Monita is not canon. There are some articles on the wiki about non canon games, such as Soulcalibur II more so than non-canon characters like Mario. I have not played Nintendoland, but from what I have seen, the only characters are Miis. It generally seems that non-canon characters only get an article on the wiki when connected directly to a non-canon game, such as Super Smash Bros. Brawl. Going by this, in my opinion, there is not enough connection for the article to be relevant in any meaningful way. Therefore, the page should be deleted or redirected to another wiki if ZeldaWiki.org still has that policy. —Yruag 11:09, 11 January 2013 (UTC)
- I'm sorry, but that still doesn't make her a notable character in a Zelda game. Just because the prizes are Zelda related doesn't mean that it's a Zelda game. I understand you put a lot of effort into making the page, and I really respect that, but it's just part of our policy that we don't cover stuff like this, especially with our NIWA affiliations.User:Justin/sig 05:33, 7 January 2013 (UTC)